Welcome to P&J Pizza- Elizabethtown
P&J Pizza- Elizabethtown, located at 22 E High St, is a beloved local eatery known for its fresh, homemade rolls and generous portions. This establishment excels in crafting delicious pizzas and subs that keep customers coming back for more. Diners rave about the thick, fresh cheesesteaks and the inviting array of toppings on pizzas, ensuring a satisfying meal every time. With a commitment to quality and reasonable prices, it’s no wonder P&J Pizza is a favorite among locals. Whether you're enjoying a casual takeout meal or hosting a party, P&J’s vibrant flavors and hearty offerings are sure to impress.
P&J Pizza- Elizabethtown: Reviews & Ratings
Had tuna sub this time. They give good portions, fresh homemade rolls, decent prices especially for what you get. And good food. I only get takeout. But highly recommend.
The subs are unsurpassed. The rolls are made in house and are delicious! I won't enjoy one from anywhere else now. Pizzas are also fabulous! Very generous with toppings and fresh pizza crust. A great place to go for either!
Wife and I went to the little oddities museum and decided to come here for lunch the cheesesteak were really good and the bread was very fresh and thick enough that it didn’t get soggy and fall apart before you can finish the onion rings and curly cheese fries are also very good.
We had a party and ordered a combination of 45 Italian and turkey cheese subs. They were ready to pick up at the time requested and all who had one of these at the party commented on how good they tasted. They had excellent fresh rolls with plenty of meat, cheese, lettuce and just enough tomatos onions for a great meal.
I am from out of state and my son and I used to eat here before he passed, we would meet when I came north. I was disappointed this trip. I ordered a lot of food for multiple people. I read my order twice at the register and a cute young man read it back, but 2 of my parties food was totally messed up and discarded. A 100.00 order should be correct. Always check your order before you leave, make this a habit everywhere because it seems noone listens or cares about service anymore. Don't think I will be stopping here anymore, my other son and I will make memories elsewhere. The sub bread is really good .
Got served by mini slim shady and food was fire
Ordered the Buffalo chicken pizza. Real chicken chunks, not ground up chicken. Tasty Buffalo sauce with a mild heat and pizza was perfectly baked. Have gone back 4 times since.
The subs are flat out amazing !!! Highly recommend the cheesteak and cheeseburger subs, you won't be disappointed. Very good staff, service and atmosphere for that old school Mom and Pop place. Prices are really good also
Location
-
22 E High St, Elizabethtown, PA 17022, United States Hotline: +1 717-367-9681
Welcome to P&J Pizza- Elizabethtown, where every bite is a celebration of flavor and freshness. Nestled in the charming town of Elizabethtown, Pennsylvania, at 22 E High St, this delightful eatery offers a menu that appeals to a wide range of palates, highlighting their commitment to quality and homemade goodness.
From the moment you step inside or place your takeout order, you are greeted with the enticing aromas of freshly baked rolls and sizzling toppings. Customers rave about the generous portions and the care taken in crafting each dish, with one patron, Mark Lively, praising their tuna sub for its impressive size and quality. It’s clear that P&J Pizza doesn’t just serve food; they curate an experience.
One of the standout features of P&J Pizza is their meticulously made in-house rolls. Pamela Hoenich sings their praises, declaring that once you’ve had a sub here, you won’t be able to enjoy one from anywhere else. The subs are not only a highlight; the pizzas are equally notable, featuring a fresh crust generously topped with quality ingredients. This is comfort food elevated to an art form.
For those seeking heartier fare, the cheesesteaks are a must-try. James Dunnigan’s experience highlights the thick, fresh bread that holds up beautifully under the weight of robust fillings, preventing sogginess and ensuring that each bite is just as satisfying as the last. And for the sides, the onion rings and curly cheese fries have received their own share of compliments, enhancing the overall meal experience.
Whether you’re dining in or picking up a large party order, P&J Pizza- Elizabethtown is dedicated to delivering quality dishes. Kevin and Sharon Cooley attest to the excellence of their turkey and Italian cheese subs, noting that guests at their party were thoroughly impressed with the quality and taste.
While not every visit is without its hiccups—as noted by Kathy Shytle's experience—it is evident that mistakes can happen anywhere. However, the fundamental elements of great food and memorable experiences echo through the walls of this beloved local joint.
In conclusion, P&J Pizza- Elizabethtown is more than just a pizza place; it’s a neighborhood gem where food is made with love and passion. The fresh ingredients, skilled preparation, and comfort of classic recipes make this spot a worthwhile destination for anyone in the Elizabethtown area. Don’t miss out on a meal that’s sure to leave you craving more!